Assault/Battery

What is Assault and Battery?

Assault and battery are two distinct but related crimes and torts under the law. While both involve harm or the threat of harm to another person, they differ in key ways. Assault refers to the intentional act of causing another person to fear imminent bodily harm, while battery refers to the actual physical contact or use of force against another person without consent.

In civil law, victims of assault and battery may pursue personal injury claims to recover compensation for their injuries, including medical expenses, pain and suffering, and emotional distress. Criminal charges can also be filed by the state or federal government, leading to possible penalties such as fines, imprisonment, or probation for the perpetrator.

Key Differences Between Assault and Battery

Assault

• Definition: Assault is defined as an intentional act that causes another person to fear imminent bodily harm. The key element of assault is the creation of fear or apprehension, not the actual contact or injury.
• Example: A person raises their fist in a threatening manner toward someone else, causing the other person to believe they are about to be hit. No physical contact is made, but the fear of harm is enough for an assault claim.

Battery

• Definition: Battery is the unlawful and intentional physical contact with another person, causing harm or offense. Battery requires actual physical contact, and it can occur even if the contact does not cause visible injury.
• Example: A person punches another person in the face without consent, resulting in a bruise or injury. This would be classified as battery.

Assault and Battery Combined

• Often, assault and battery occur together. For example, someone might threaten to hit someone (assault), and then follow through with the action (battery).
• Example: A person verbally threatens to harm another, and then physically punches the victim. Both assault and battery have occurred in this situation.

Types of Assault and Battery

Simple Assault and Battery

• This occurs when there is an intentional act of threat (assault) or physical contact (battery) without serious injury or aggravating factors. This is usually considered a misdemeanor.
• Example: A person shoves another in a bar after a verbal altercation, leading to minor bruising or no visible injuries.

Aggravated Assault and Battery

• Aggravated assault and battery involve additional factors that elevate the severity of the crime or tort. These include using a weapon, causing significant injury, or targeting vulnerable individuals. Aggravated offenses are typically classified as felonies.
• Example: A person attacks someone with a baseball bat, causing serious injury. This would be classified as aggravated battery due to the use of a weapon and the severity of the injury.

Sexual Assault

• Sexual assault is a form of battery involving unwanted sexual contact, including groping, fondling, or other non-consensual touching. In some jurisdictions, sexual assault laws may overlap with or be considered a form of battery.
• Example: An individual is touched inappropriately by another person without consent, leading to both criminal charges and civil claims for battery.

Domestic Assault and Battery

• Domestic assault and battery involve harm or threats of harm within a domestic setting, such as between spouses, partners, or family members. These cases often involve unique legal considerations, including restraining orders and domestic violence statutes.
• Example: A spouse physically assaults their partner in a domestic dispute, leading to both criminal charges and a civil personal injury claim.

Child Abuse and Battery

• Child abuse claims can involve battery if a child is physically harmed by a parent, caregiver, or other adult. In these cases, the harm is often more severe, and legal action may result in both criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages.
• Example: A caregiver hits a child in the face, causing bruising and emotional distress. The child may pursue a personal injury claim for the harm caused.

Legal Elements of Assault and Battery Claims

To pursue a civil claim for assault or battery, the plaintiff must generally prove the following elements:

Intentional Act

• The defendant must have acted intentionally, meaning they deliberately sought to cause fear (assault) or physical contact (battery) with the plaintiff. In cases where the defendant acted negligently or accidentally, the claim may not meet the threshold for assault or battery.

Lack of Consent

• For a battery claim to succeed, the plaintiff must prove that they did not consent to the contact. In some cases, mutual combat or consent (such as in a fight or sports event) can serve as a defense to battery claims.

Harm or Threat of Harm

• The plaintiff must show that they either experienced physical harm or were placed in reasonable fear of imminent harm (assault). In the case of battery, actual harm (e.g., bruising, lacerations, or emotional distress) must be proven.

Causation

• There must be a direct link between the defendant’s actions and the plaintiff’s injuries. For example, if the plaintiff’s injuries were caused by something unrelated (e.g., an accident), the defendant may not be held liable for the assault or battery.

Defenses to Assault and Battery Claims

There are several common defenses to assault and battery claims, including:

Consent

• If the plaintiff consented to the physical contact or threat, then the defendant may have a valid defense. This is commonly seen in cases involving contact sports, fights, or certain forms of performance (e.g., medical procedures).
• Example: Two people engage in a mutual fight where both agree to physical contact. In this case, the defendant can argue that the plaintiff consented to the physical altercation.

Self-Defense

• If the defendant can prove they acted in self-defense to protect themselves from harm, this may be a valid defense. The defendant must show that their response was reasonable under the circumstances and proportionate to the threat.
• Example: A person punches another in self-defense after the other person threatens them with a weapon.

Defense of Others

• Similar to self-defense, if the defendant can prove they acted to protect someone else from harm, this can serve as a defense to assault or battery claims.
• Example: A person pushes another away from a friend who is being attacked, causing no serious injury to the aggressor. The defendant may argue they were protecting the other individual.

Defense of Property

• If the defendant used force to protect their property (such as in cases of burglary or trespassing), they may argue that their actions were justified. However, the level of force must be reasonable.
• Example: A homeowner uses physical force to stop a burglar from entering their home. The force must be proportional to the threat of harm.

Insanity or Lack of Mental Capacity

• In rare cases, a defendant may argue that they lacked the mental capacity to understand the consequences of their actions. This defense is more commonly seen in criminal cases but may also be used in civil claims if the defendant’s mental state is at issue.
• Example: The defendant is found to have been suffering from a severe mental illness at the time of the assault and was unaware of the harm they caused.

Remedies Available in Assault and Battery Cases

Compensatory Damages

• Victims of assault and battery are typically entitled to compensatory damages to cover medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. In cases of significant injury, the victim may be entitled to compensation for long-term physical or emotional consequences.
• Example: A person who is physically assaulted and requires surgery for a broken bone may receive compensation for their medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

Punitive Damages

• In cases where the defendant’s behavior is particularly egregious or malicious (e.g., a premeditated attack or excessive force), punitive damages may be awarded to punish the defendant and deter future misconduct.
• Example: If a defendant repeatedly assaults someone over a period of time with the intent to cause severe harm, the court may award punitive damages in addition to compensatory damages.

Injunctive Relief

• In some cases, especially involving ongoing threats or harassment, the victim may seek injunctive relief, which requires the defendant to cease certain behaviors or actions.
• Example: A victim of repeated threats or harassment may seek an injunction to prevent the defendant from coming near them or contacting them in the future.

Emotional Distress Damages

• In addition to physical harm, victims of assault and battery may be awarded damages for emotional distress, which may include anxiety, PTSD, or other psychological effects caused by the attack.
• Example: A victim of a violent assault who suffers from anxiety and fear following the attack may be awarded damages for the emotional impact of the incident.

Medical Expenses and Lost Wages

• Victims of assault and battery are entitled to compensation for medical expenses incurred as a result of the injury, as well as any wages lost due to time spent recovering from the injury.
• Example: If a person misses work after a violent assault, they may recover the wages lost during their recovery period.

Legal Actions in Assault and Battery Cases

Filing a Civil Lawsuit

• Victims of assault and battery can file a civil lawsuit to seek damages for the harm they have suffered. This action is separate from any criminal charges and can result in financial compensation.
• Example: A person who has been assaulted at a nightclub may file a lawsuit against the perpetrator for damages, even if the perpetrator faces criminal charges for the assault.

Criminal Charges

• In addition to civil actions, the state may file criminal charges for assault and battery. Criminal penalties can include jail time, probation, fines, or restitution to the victim.
• Example: If the assault was severe, the defendant may face criminal prosecution and imprisonment for their actions.

Relevant Legal Articles and Statutes

• California Penal Code §§ 240-242 – Defines assault and battery
• Federal Civil Rights Laws (42 U.S.C. § 1983) – In cases involving police brutality or civil rights violations
• Restatement (Second) of Torts – Definitions and principles related to tort actions for assault and battery
• State-Specific Assault and Battery Laws – Varies by jurisdiction

Sun: Closed

Mon: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Tues: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Wed: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Thurs: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Sat: Closed